NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Always Keepin' It Tight Eyeliner Pencil, Gray

I wish it would last longer?

Seems this eyeliner gets a lot of bad reviews. When used as intended, this liner is outstanding. I use it on my upper waterline only. It glides on easily with superb coverage. It is not intended for you upper or lower lids on dry skin. Yes, then it will drag and break. Try your upper waterline, you'll never go back.

it works good but its not the product listed. its a regular nyx retractable eyeliner. keeping it tight was thinner and not a blend able product. it went on and stayed put. this one is creamy needs an eyeshadow to set it which you cant do in your waterline. definitely too expensive for little product. used to be $5 at ulta.

This pencil is super thin. I felt like I was poking my eye. I threw it out.

Super skinny, stays put, easy application. Excellent for precise eyeliner application. I’ve tried several other brands of the super skinny and this is my favorite.

I have ordered two different NYX automatic sharpening pencils on two different sites and both arrived defective. This one the inside part keeps falling out. I can use it if I shove it back in the base but I ordered another brand so I can throw this one away. Second case from another store it wouldn't come up at all. There are better pencils out there - I would avoid NYX. This also went on too sheer for my liking and came off a short time later. All in all not a good product.

This pencil is great! I didn’t have to apply much pressure while using it, it glides on very well! And very pigmented!

Love it. Not a ton of nude eye liners out there. This one is a great color for white/medium coloring. Good price too.