Mechanical Eye Pencil, Vivid Rich Mechanical, Creamy Retractable Eyeliner - Under the Moonstone, Slate Grey Eyeliner

Edit: bought 3 times. 2nd time lacked pigment, but they sent me a free replacement and it was good. I got the NYX Mechnical Eyeliner in the onyx (black) shade. It is absolutely stunning! It is definitely washable, not waterproof. This is what I was seeking as I do not like using makeup remover and prefer for all my makeup to wash away in the shower with a gentle facial cleanser. I find that makeup removers can be harsh on skin and can tear some eyelashes out. The NYX eyeliner can smudge throughout the day, but it takes a LOT to smudge. I took two naps, had wind blown in my face, and planted a tree and it remained perfect on my oily eyeliner with no primer. It did not last as long on my waterline, but that's to be expected, probably a few hours max. I haven't worn eyeliner in years now but I remembered recently that I really enjoyed applying it back in the day. I was shocked how easy it was to apply. I remember I used to use a product called Rimmel Scandal Eyes and this NYX eyeliner is incredible comparatively. It is so pigmented yet more smudge resistant. It glides on smoothly and is easy to shape. It is firm and does not seem like it will break. I am very satisfied with this product and highly recommend to anyone looking for a very pigmented pencil eyeliner that is washable yet smudge resistant! Great price as well.

NYX retractable eyeliner is the best! It stays on well and they have great colors. An excellent value and better than some more costly brands!

Intense color and definitely stays on all day. The color is the perfect balance between brown and black. Only issue is the retractable pencil is soft and it does break off. Otherwise, it’s a great eyeliner, easy to apply.

It’s a nice eye liner. Goes on smoothly.

my go to for eyeliner. it's inexpensive, comes in gorgeous colors, applies nicely and stays on, but it does smudge easily on the skin

A very cool golden taupe brownish magical color. Staying power. Doesn’t smear. Looks pretty under the lower lashes. I’ll do black liner, sone shadow and mascara- then draw a thin line under my lower lashes. I love the subtle glittery shimmer. I’m middle aged and I need some sparkle! It’s subtle and interesting. I will be buying this again. It’s attractive and interesting and I think it’s fun without being loud, clowny, glitter faced or juvenile.

i don’t want to say it sucks completely bc it definitely lasts as u can see in the pic i drew a heart yesterday and it’s still kinda there. it sets quickly and when u rub it nothing comes off. i’m only giving it 3 stars bc it’s not comfortable on the eyes. i specifically bought this for my waterline and it irritated my eyes a bit and it faded after like 45 minutes. it also made them a little red and i was feeling dry. i use to use this gel liner but the label faded and i can’t find it so i just went for this one and im upset. waste of money IN MY OPINION, not saying it sucks but everyone has their different uses for this it didn’t work for me personally. i find it dumb how some makeup brands don’t make these type of crayon like eyeliner pencils WATERLINE SAFE/comfy as if most ppl didn’t use them IN their waterline. for winged liner almost everyone uses liquid liner so they should at least make these types suitable for ur damn waterline. at least it was cheap so i’m not too mad i definitely won’t repurchase tho bc i wouldn’t really put this to use. buy if u want or dont just know its not waterline safe, it lasts outside ur eye 100% but it also sets fast so depending on how u do ur makeup it u will know if it works well for u or not

This is by far the best eyeliner I’ve ever used. I only used the most expensive brands of eyeliners for 30. Years. I went from one expensive brand to another and decided to try this. It goes on great and stays on all day. I always say you get what you pay for but not with makeup.