Question 1

I'm not seeing the ingredients, could anyone let me know what the first few ingredients are.  wondering if this is as good as new life spectrum.

Accepted Answer

I have 5 wide bodied goldfish - veil tailed and orandas in an outdoor pond. They are finicky little (6-7  inch) #**%#!#; who really call into question this entire goldfish are gluttonous eaters stereotypes. I have many food products as a result. Here are my answers.

First 3 ingredients on my labels
Hikari: Fish meal, wheatgerm meal and dried brewer's yeast.
NLS: Krill, Squid, whole wheat flour.
As you know:
Any fish ingredient  is there for protein unless it is to provide astaxanthin for color. 
Wheatgerm helps fish hold on to fat reserves. 
But
Wheat flour does not really help the fish. It is mostly for us. It holds the ingredients together so it is easier for us to feed the fish.

Who is better?
In my opinion, they are both comparable and here is why.
To me, NLS is not superior as wheat flour is *probably* the primary ingredient. See, it is not just the order of ingredients alone,  but in the case of dry food, the first dry ingredient is the one with the most presence in the food.  Pet food manufacturers use fresh weight to try and make their food look better than it is.

That said, the ingredients that NLS do use *may* be cleaner or of higher quality given that they specify the exact type of fish they use. Hikari just says "fish meal".

I use Hikari out of necessity as my fish will not eat NLS, Blue Ridge or any of the popular fishfood brands  and then I start to worry about their health even though I know they are way too fat to starve any time soon.

However I believe the absolute best thing you can feed your goldfish is Repashy. (which of course like all healthy, good for you food, my goldfish reject.)

Hope that helps.

Question 2

Does this bag cause goldfish to turn orange? I used the lionhead one and it turned my all black fish orange and same with my all white one.

Accepted Answer

Black is an unstable color in fancy goldfish. Many, if not most, fancies (excluding black moors) will turn from black to red/orange as they get older. It doesn't have anything to do with the food...just an evolutionary leftover from when they were carp & black juveniles were less likely to be eaten and bright red adults had an easier time finding mates.

Question 3

How am I supposed to be snacking on these crackers?

Accepted Answer

I am going to assume this is a serious question and answer that this is food for fish, gold fish specifically.  This is an excellent food for goldfish. It is a sinking food which is supposed to be best for their swim bladder. My goldfish seemed to really like this brand of food, they would go after it with gusto.

Question 4

Are these food pellets really 3cms?  that's over 1 inch in us.  my fish are only 3 to 4 inches.

Accepted Answer

These pellets are much smaller than 3cms. I don't have a metric measure but would guess they are really more like 3mm. 3 to 4 inch goldfish would have no trouble eating them.

Product Dimensions	11 x 11 x 11 cm; 200 g
Item model number	49340
Breed Recommendation	All Breed Sizes
Pet Life Stage	All Life Stages
Flavor	Fish
Item Form	Granule
Allergen Information	Allergen-Free
Volume	1 Milliliters
Number of Items	1
Quantity	1
Storage Information	Store in a cool, dry place.
Specific Uses	Improved Growth, Color Enhancement
batteries required	No
Batteries Included	No
Item Weight	200 g

HikariSaki Fancy Goldfish Color 200G

Details

Description

Specifications

Have a Question? See What Others Asked

Reviews

Common Questions