COVERGIRL Get In Line Liquid Eyeliner, Black Crystal, Long Lasting, 0.08 Ounces, Feather-Fine Tip, Contour-Grip Handle, Quick-Dry Liquid Eyeliner, Removes Easily (Pack of 2)

Normally I am a Sephora girlie, but there are a few items that just can not be beat by those "luxury" brands. This eyeliner is absolutely one of them. I used to use Urban Decay Perversion or something "edgy" like that, but when they discontinued it, I scrambled to try out a few different brands, and omg this dark horse galloped on ahead and became my Black Beauty (hahaha - I'm sorry, I couldn't help myself, I'll stop): - The wand tip is sharp and tiny, allowing precise lines, and it keeps it's shape as long as you are gentle/accurate about screwing the top back on (I have jammed it in a hurry so that's my own fault) - The actual eyeliner is a dark, dark black, none of that watery or gray ish. I get the matte one and yeah...it's matte, no shine or shimmer. It is so smooth and just glides on like it owns your eyelids. - It really does own your eyelids. The staying power on this is crazy, I've been messy before and fallen asleep with a full face on, woke up the next morning and it was basically still perfect. A little smudged but still THERE. It doesn't chip and sprinkle which is 1 of my biggest peeves with eye make up. - Although this isn't waterproof, it still holds up really well. I like that it is so easy to remove when you actually want to remove it. I've bought this eyeliner like 25× now, I've been using it for years and only now sat down to give it the praise it deserves. My boyfriend has heard our history (me & this eyeliner) and my sworn statements that "I will never EVER buy another eyeliner" enough times, so I'll just post that soliloquy here to give him a break...for now.

Love the application and hard to find in local drug stores

I love this eyeliner. The tip is precise and firm, making it easy to draw everything from a thin line to a thick wing. It stays put throughout the day and doesn't smudge at all. Definitely one of my favorite liners out there…

I really like this liquid liner. It's my first time using a brush wand instead of the liquid pens. At first, I used way too much product so it resulted in a hot mess on my first attempt. And then I learned that you have to treat the product like nail polish, where you scrape the excess product in the bottle before application. Once you have the right amount of product on your brush, it's like magic. You glide it straight across one eye, reapply and dab off the excess, and glide it across the other eye. All done in less than 60 seconds. The brush tip is so thin that you get a precise line every time. You can also build it up to a thick cat eye for a bolder look. The longevity is debatable. On the first day, by the end of the night I noticed that it faded away. On day 2, I noticed that it kept its shape and opacity, and didn't flake or fade at all. And I live in a humid climate, so it was actually pretty impressive that it lasted. Overall, I enjoy the product and the ease of application. And you can't beat the price!

My all-time favorite! I’ve strayed from this particular eyeliner a few times, looking for something “better“. Every time, I’m unhappy with the results. This is the only one that I find I can do lines steadily, ranging from extremely thin, to thick. It doesn’t smudge or flake either! When you wash it, it comes off easily with soap. Has kind of a shine to it once it dries. My only complaint is that it seems to clump after a while at the opening of the bottle. Lasts a month or two for me. Just try it! It’s worth the money. You won’t be disappointed.

Did yall know a migraine can mimic a stroke? I didn't. Anyway through all the test and crying, my makeup stayed, when I finally left the ER in the dead of night, I got compliments on my makeup on the way out. It literally didn't move the entire time.

Formula: This eyeliner has a ball inside the tube when shaking it up. The formula reminds me of Maybelline Stiletto, which I like! I prefer this type of formula over Revlon Colorstay Connect the Dots. Both Covergirl and Maybelline can flake off if I rub into them. If I don’t touch it, it lasts all day without smudging. It’s very easy to remove, hassle-free. I can remove it cleanly with just water and no raccoon eyes! When you want to draw a thin line, make sure to remove the excess liquid because this Covergirl applicator can get pretty wet and runny. Applicator: The applicator is probably the thinnest point I have tried so far. While it is impressively thin, it is too bendy/flexible for drawing wings and too thin for drawing throughout lids. Unfortunately, I won’t repurchase since it doesn’t suit my needs. It might have been perfect if it was firm. It seems like a felt tip but is it? I never used a brush tip before so I’m unsure. Other thoughts: Maybelline Stiletto is easier to fill in my lids but it’s a little thick to create a wing. I have to use 2-3 types of eyeliner to get a decent cat eye (I’m terrible, I know). I use NYX Curve Liner or Milani Eye Tech Perfection liquid liner to outline and “stamp” the wings. Those do not stay moist long so that’s where Covergirl was supposed to come in to fix it (but tip is too flexible). Products shown in photos: -CoverGirl Get in Line Liquid Eyeliner (320/Major Matte Black) -Milani Eye Tech Perfection Liquid Eyeliner -Revlon Colorstay Connect the Dots -Maybelline Line Stiletto Ultimate Precision Liquid Eyeliner

Update: based on all the great reviews and me really wanting grey eyeliner, I purchased this eyeliner at the store. IT'S PERFECT!! It's not lumpy or a weird color!! I'm so happy! This eyeliner is so easy to apply, and I'm terrible at liquid liner, and stays put all day. And it doesn't fall off in chunks. I'm very fair and have grey hair, so black and brown liners are too harsh. THIS liner is perfect!! I must have received a really old liner thru Amazon. I ordered the grey and it's the weirdest liner I've ever had. It's the consistency of lumpy liquid paper. When dry, it's a strange whitish-grey color that is just weird. After a while it started falling off in chucks. Maybe I got an old batch.

I've been using this liquid liner for years and I won't use any other one. It is very good, very black and really lasts. I find it extremely easy to use with the tip. But I do have to say that the packaging needs to be looked at because it breaks off and cracks and it gets hard to use and I cant get the tip out of the pot unless I twist it a certain way.

Great hold for everyday look, dont recommand for under eye if its watery, love the tiny and precise brush, great pigment!

It’s not the blackest black, in any capacity. It’s not opaque, regardless of how you try to build it up. However, it doesn’t crumble, smear or budge. It also has the FINEST brush tip I’ve ever handled and to get a sharp wing it’s SO SIMPLE. Perfect for fine lines and detailed looks, BIG FAN.

Beautiful shade of grey. I'm not a cat eye fan, so I don't know if it's the right consistency for that, but it goes on easy and stays on all day even without primer.

This is a really good liquid eyeliner for the price. It goes on smoothly, and the brush is well-designed (no flaring.) It's not a premium brand and occasionally one will need to go over the lines a second time because the colour distribution can be just a little bit uneven, but for its price this is my favourite eyeliner. And it definitely lasts all day long. (Be prepared for a double swipe of your eye makeup remover. This is a plus in my book!)