L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner, Waterproof and Smudge-Resistant, Glides on Easily to Create any Look, Burgundy, 0.042 oz.

For years I have had an issue with eyeliner running under my eyes even with primers and setting sprays. A friend recommended this L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pro-last Pencil Eyeliner to me since it is waterproof and smudge resistant. From the first time I tried it I was impressed. It goes on easily and smoothly. It does not run during the day or irritate my eyes like some waterproof eyeliners do. After that I ordered several in brown just to make sure I had them on hand. Since then I have re-ordered this eyeliner several times in different colors. It's great quality and a great value. I'm glad I found it.

I’ve been very impressed with this eyeliner pencil. It glides on smoothly without tugging or pulling on the delicate skin around my eyes, making application quick and easy. The color goes on evenly and provides great definition. What I love most is how long-lasting it is. Once applied, it stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading, and I rarely need any touch-ups. Even after a full day of wear, it still looks fresh. If you’re looking for an eyeliner that is easy to apply, comfortable to wear, and truly long-lasting, this is an excellent choice. I will definitely continue purchasing it.

this has been my favorite eyeliner for YEARS. it’s never irritated my eyes and it stays on for the entire day on my waterline and is a dark black. it doesn’t sharpen well without breaking but i find i don’t need to sharpen it and can just use my finger to make it into a wing. the texture is smooth and smudges well until it is dried down, but the eyeliner itself dries out before i can finish it. it comes off with micellar water or face wash.

I have only used this one time but it’s so much better than any of the other dark brown gel pencils I have ever used and I probably have 4 other brands in my drawer right now. I’ve had it on for hours. Zero smudging and I have oily eye lids. I’m amazed! I thought I needed to go the expensive route and visited ulta. The young girl suggested urban decay which I fell for. It was more than twice the cost of this wonderful L’Oréal infallible pencil and not retractable! 😱. I returned it today and thankfully my new L’Oréal came today which I immediately applied. I’m so excited that I finally found a good waterproof no smudge gel eyeliner! Color is great. East to apply. Glides on nicely.

*The lighting is not great in my video. For better reference, I have between very light to light and neutral toned skin on the back of my hand. My face color is actually darker... falling between light and light-medium and taking on a slightly warmer tone (when comparing to the spectrum of very basic concealer colors found in most drugstores). This will explain how I'm able to use the eyeliner the way I do given the way it shows up on my hand in the video. I thought this liner would be a bit lighter than it actually was. Turns out it was just a 1-2 shades light enough for me to use as a faint highlighter on my brow bones and under my eyes, towards the inner corners. It doesn't look good on my water-line (right above the lower lashes). It ends up making me look sickly and weird if I try to wear it like that. It matches too closely with my overall skin color/shade and makes the little bit of warmth I have on my face look like a washed out yellow tone. It basically makes me look like I have glossy eyeballs, tiny eyes, a weird bottom lash line, and questionable for jaundice. (It might work better on the water line for people with darker skin or possibly cooler skin tones.) I'd consider the bright nude to have a mostly neutral tone. People with pale, fair skin likely couldn't use it for highlighting and brightening. I think it would be too dark. It's like a pale nude color. Those with fair to light skin may actually be able to use it as a concealer. (It would probably make a great spot concealer, TBH.) This liner has a lot of great qualities about it... The mechanical pencil design works well. The liner is firm enough not to melt all over the place if you try to apply it like an eyeliner. But it goes on smoothly so there's no need for a lot of pressure or tugging. The cap seals securely and prevents it from drying out. The pigment is rich, even for such a pale color. There is a pencil sharpener built in on the end with the sponge tip. I haven't needed to use it for this liner given I use it as a highlighter/brightener. But it has come in handy with my other eyeliner that doesn't have a built in sharpener. The sponge tip is adequate and actually works for blending. I use it a little aggressively and haven't had any plastic or rough parts poke thru yet. It's easy to wash, too. Even though the liner glides on smooth and creamy, it sets very quickly. I guess this could be a good or bad thing depending on how you want to use the liner. I could see it being beneficial for those who are able to use this on their water line. But for me, it's a bit of a nuisance. (Watch the video & see why.) This liner is amongst the last things I'll apply to my face when wearing make up. It's because I have to move fast to get it to blend smoothly. I can't just drag the color over an area and wait to blend it later. I really don't have much time to fumble with other things, like looking for my favorite beauty blender. When this thing sets in place, it's pretty much set. It's easily blendable within the first 10 seconds of applying it. After that, it begins to "dry" in place. I'm still able to blend it after 10 seconds, but the more I wait, the more difficult it becomes to blend away all streakiness. If I wait more than a minute, it becomes too much of a hassle to try to blend around my sensitive eye skin. But this liner will blend. And if done properly, it blends beautifully. It almost seems to disappear into my skin or become gradient with other colors. Sometimes I'll blend this with dots of frosted white liner for a brighter effect. The bright nude color is matte, so even though it works as a highlighter, the effect it has is pretty subtle. I would buy this item again. I would recommend it to others. I would just caution that it may not work out as expected if you're skin is very light or beyond. Still, it's blendable. It makes a great base for powder eye shadow and blends well with other creamy stick liners. I'd be interested in buying other colors from this line. The bright nude liner has been impressively smudge resistant, waterproof, and long lasting. I don't have to touch up thru out the day. I just have to worry about applying it properly the first time and getting it all off at night.

I have been looking for a gel eyeliner pencil that stays on all day and I finally found one that’s both economical and easy to apply. I purchased originally the black which I love and just purchased the brown shade. If you want all day where this eyeliner this is for you. It does require eye makeup remover to take off.

Color is perfect. Glides on easily but smudges and rubs off easily if there's even a hint of oil (e.g. from foundation or primer) on your eyelids.

Love this eye pencil. Stays all day, even on my more oily eyelids. It’s a keeper! I use the Brown so can’t vouch for the other colors at this point.

This is super nice eye liner I was looking for . Those who have watery eye eye and need good eye liner this is the right choice

Beautiful colour, long wear time, no smudging, no raccoon eyes after 10+ hours. Needs a good sharpener as the wood is hard. I will definitely buy this again rather than spending $20+ for a Lise watier metallic brown pencil (not retractable either) which doesn't last as long and smudges by the end of the day. I wish there would be more metallic colours like this one.

Love the color and soft texture, glides on smooth , no pulling at skin.

Just loved it, it lasts all day, easy to remove with vaseline.

The L’Oréal Paris Infallible Grip 36H Gel Mechanical White Liner in "Polar White" has become a staple in my makeup routine! The color is a true, vibrant white that instantly brightens my eyes and makes me look more awake. The texture is smooth and glides effortlessly across my waterline without tugging. It's highly pigmented, so you don’t need multiple passes to get a bold look. Plus, it dries quickly and stays put all day long—no smudging or fading, even after hours of wear! The fact that it’s waterproof is a huge bonus. I’ve worn it through workouts and humid days, and it holds up perfectly. The mechanical design is super convenient; no sharpening is needed, which saves time. Whether you’re going for a subtle highlight or a bold graphic liner look, this eyeliner delivers. Highly recommend it for anyone looking to brighten their eyes with a long-lasting formula! 🖤